Disclosure: Melina is a good friend. On the other hand, I'd bought my own copy before she offered to send me one.
This is a new thing; a properly thought out instructional work for social dancing of Argentine Tango, which aims to give a comprehensive basic course. As far as I know, there isn't any other work that attempts the same thing with anywhere near the same ambition. I was looking forward to this book with some interest, since Melina and Detlef's regular students are reliably easy and fun to dance with, sometimes exceptionally musical, and always individual.
I like the book, and I like the DVD. It's suitable for all levels. Beginners will find an excellent guide to basic technique, musicality, and social dancing. Non-beginners will find the same, and a structured troubleshooting manual. Professionals will find well-tested effective teaching ideas.
For beginners: I suggest you start with the DVD and watch the whole thing. A few unfamiliar words will appear without being introduced, but it doesn't matter. You're likely to have questions: at that point, refer to the book, which will answer them in lots of detail.
Non-beginners: either do the same, or you might like to start by looking up in the book whatever interests you most. Then watch the first hour of the DVD, then go back to the beginning and work through the whole thing using them together.
The fundamental usefulness of this work is that it embodies a practical, progressive, thought-out plan for learning to dance well. You start with posture, embrace, and communication. You go on to
walking, changes of lane, then changes of system, and pivots, in that
order, all with detailed instructions and exercises to make sure you have control of what you are doing, and freedom to improvise. The technique guide
in chapters 1-14 is logically arranged and progressive, so that spending time on the
earlier parts will be rewarded later and you can tell where to go back to if you get stuck.
At this point I would suggest flipping forward to chapter 20, which is devoted to the broader, less technical aspects of following
and the follower's full role in the dance. I think many beginners
would find it encouraging as well as helpful and important, and I would have put it at the end of the technique section instead of near the end of the book.
Next comes an introduction to the
structure and characteristics of tango music, with chapters on rhythmic diversity, phrasing, and musical exercises to make your dance - in either role - more interesting.
The chapters of tips and experiences for social dancing and
community-building would be as useful and time-saving for teachers and
organisers as for students of the dance. Finally, there are tips on practicing and making the best use of teachers. And there's a very handy troubleshooting checklist hidden on page
156.
The diagrams and photos are clearly printed and of high
quality, and looking closely at the drawings sometimes reveals an idea not spelled out in the text. The presentantion in general is not super-slick looking, but it does the job.
It is comprehensive, in the sense that if you can manage the techniques and have a reasonable grasp of the rest of it, you are well equipped for social dancing anywhere you want to go. For certain situations you'll need some extra techniques, but, to be honest, I rarely actually use anything that isn't either in here, or just a more complex application of the same ideas that requires more practice and physical skill. The only thing I use somewhat regularly that isn't covered is an open or fluid social embrace, which many people never use at all. Depending on where you are, this may or may not be a problem.
It stops before explicitly discussing turns. But it does cover all the techniques you need to do various kinds of turns, and it's very reasonable to assume that you'll be taking classes as well as using the book, especially if you are a beginner. In that case you'll discover how to apply the techniques to turns, and if you're not a beginner it will be obvious anyway.
It's very, very difficult to explain dance movements clearly in words,
and it is all the harder in a dance where there are no real rules and
very few conventions. Overall, Melina and Detlef do an outstandingly good job of it.
I recommend reading slowly. The English is perfectly fluent and clear, with excellent pronunciation on the DVD, but not native. Errors of
word choice are minor; 'harmonic' instead of 'harmonious', Latin plurals for parts of the body, surprising mid-sentence changes of register, and a few invented-but-obvious or correct-but-obsolete words. None of this matters in speech, and non-native readers of
English will probably not
even notice them in writing. The only one that I think really needs fixing
is the brain-bending "down-over-up", which sounds like some sort of quantum tunnelling. They mean down, sideways, and up. Not a problem on the DVD, where you can clearly see what is happening, so if you watch the DVD first, it won't puzzle you. There's an errata page to clear this up, along with couple of errors in diagrams and on the DVD.
The writing is clear, but not always concise. They give detailed reasons for every single statement of advice. This is a good thing, but mixing instruction and explanation in
the same paragraph makes the instructions seem longer than they really are. If you simply note what you
are being told to do and then do it, you will find that the instructions are easy to follow, practical, and reliable, and will give you a good,
natural basic technique that minimises stress on the body and works well
in a very wide range of situations. This is why their regular students
dance very individually while being reliably easy to lead and follow.
It also means that much more detail is provided than most people will need. Extra detail sections are provided for those who like them. You will know if that is you or not.
The great thing about having a book is that you can use the material
in the way you learn best. As an adult who has taken classes, you
probably know what format works for you. My natural approach to each
chapter is to read the how-to, read the exercises, glance at the
introduction to check how it all fits in, and finally look at the detail
section to see if there's anything there that I like. Then I go back
to the exercises and note in my own words what I am being asked to
do, which can usually be very brief, and try whatever it is in my weekly practice session. So far, I've always had satisfying results.
I found the explanation of how to lead pivots exceptionally helpful -
just having it clearer in my head produced an immediate improvement in
clarity, in confidence, and in the range of movements I could improvise
successfully. The explanation of how, physically, to pivot as follower
or leader without hurting yourself or throwing yourself off balance is
outstanding. This is an important topic, as it's very easy to get
injured when trying to practice on your own. I also think my leading will benefit a lot from the exercises on musicality.
The DVD picture is not high definition, but it's well lit and well
filmed. You can see a small excerpt on Melina's recent blog post about posture. The sound of the recorded voices is a little echoey at times;
not enough to be a serious problem, but it is a bit annoying and
detracts from the impression of quality given by the rather beautiful
studio. There are quite a few sight gags in the DVD, in a style that will be
very familiar to Melina and Detlef's regular students, but I don't think
there are any Easter eggs. Tell me if you find one.
Overall, I think the book and DVD together are extremely valuable as a structured guide to fundamental
techniques, and as a reference and troubleshooting manual for study
and practice alone, with a partner, or in a group.
I would add, for those who take a lot of classes and notice these things, that chapters 1 to maybe 5 or 6 of the book, and the corresponding DVD material, cover (in a lot more detail and with marginally different emphasis) the same material as Carlitos and Noelia do in their first one or two walking-and-embrace workshops of a basic set. It's explained and visualised differently, but as someone who's done both I can tell you that if you paid attention in either, in my opinion you'd end up doing the same physical thing. That's convergent evolution for you. By all means do both, if you like; they certainly won't conflict.
I am also about 60% sure that one of the stranger moments in the DVD is really an excerpt of a
cutting-edge South-East-European Ex-Communist-Surrealist satirical art
project. But only about 60%. They might be completely serious.
Available directly from http://www.caminarabrazados.com/ or via Amazon (but with low 'long-tail' stock, so you're unlikely to get it any quicker, and the authors get less out of it, but it's up to you).
Tuesday 22 December 2015
Review: Caminar Abrazados - Instructional Book and DVD
Posted by msHedgehog at 00:51
Labels: argentine tango
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
4 comments:
Very useful review, thank-you.
"It is comprehensive, in the sense that if you can manage the techniques and have a reasonable grasp of the rest of it, you are well equipped for social dancing anywhere you want to go."
Allowing that different people learn in different ways and indeed have varying amounts of free time, energy, available practicas etc, roughly speaking how much time and effort would it take for a beginner and a reasonable intermediate dancer to get to the above stage?
I don't think that's remotely predictable. You might make a guess for a specific student you personally knew, but any general prediction would be obvious nonsense.
That said, I think anyone should be able to find at least one or two important improvements, from their own point of view, within their own personal learning cycle. If you know how long it usually takes you to change something, and you don't sabotage yourself by trying to do things in an order that doesn't make sense, or by perfectionism, then you should be able to get there within about eight to twelve cycles for an intermediate who is mainly fixing problems, or maybe twelve to eighteen for a relative beginner. In many cases the main problem will be finding the right partners to work with - everything takes much longer without that. Although you can learn a lot just by dancing socially in the right frame of mind.
I don't think this book is ideal for complete beginners, but it would certainly be a useful reference and a lot of help if intelligently used. I don't know of any other work that would be better.
Thank you for making me aware of this interesting new resource. Your comprehensive, helpful review made it clear that I needed to check this out, and I've now ordered my copies.
@David Phillips: Enjoy! Do let us know how you got on with it.
Post a Comment